Why "Best in Brooklyn" Is the Wrong Question to Start With

Brooklyn has more distinct neighborhood identities than almost any comparable urban area — Park Slope and Bushwick are both Brooklyn, but they have almost nothing in common in terms of price, buyer pool, or transaction character. A search for "the best realtor in Brooklyn" implies a single ranking that doesn't actually exist; what exists instead is a wide range of agents with different concentrations of experience across the borough's neighborhoods.

The more useful question is: which agent has specific, verifiable, recent transaction experience in the neighborhood and price range relevant to your situation? An agent's overall closed volume and years of experience are a starting filter — they establish whether someone has done this work seriously and successfully over time. From there, the specific neighborhood fit is what actually matters for your transaction.

Tami Earnest's Brooklyn Experience

Tami Earnest is a Licensed Real Estate Salesperson with Compass who has completed 1,300+ transactions and $164M+ in sales volume over 14 years across Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Westchester County, with a Wall Street Journal top 1.5% national ranking based on closed transaction volume.

Her Brooklyn work spans the borough's range — from the brownstone belt's co-op and townhouse transactions to condo sales in Brooklyn's newer development corridors. She has worked with first-time buyers navigating their first co-op board package, families weighing school zones against space and budget, and sellers managing the borough's specific seller closing cost structure, including flip tax considerations on co-op sales.

What buyers and sellers consistently note about working with her: she presents comparable sales data plainly, including when it doesn't support the price a seller hoped for, and she is direct about whether a specific Brooklyn neighborhood actually fits a buyer's stated priorities rather than steering toward whatever listing is most convenient.

The Value of Cross-Market Comparison

A meaningful share of Brooklyn buyers are comparing Brooklyn against Manhattan, and a meaningful share of Brooklyn sellers are evaluating a move out to Westchester. Tami's active work in all three markets means she can speak to these comparisons directly — what a given budget buys in Park Slope versus the Upper West Side, or what selling a Brooklyn co-op and buying in Westchester actually involves financially and procedurally — rather than offering general impressions of markets she doesn't transact in regularly.

Frequently Asked Questions